AI Won’t Replace You, But a Smarter Fundraiser Might

Written By kere talovic

AI is not coming for your job. But it is changing it.

In the nonprofit world, especially for frontline fundraisers and development officers, artificial intelligence can feel like both a threat and a promise. You hear phrases like “predictive analytics,” “donor modeling,” and “automated touchpoints,” and wonder where that leaves you in the mix.

The truth? You won’t be replaced by AI. But you could be replaced by someone who knows how to use it well. Let’s make sure that someone is you.

Let the Bots Do the Boring Stuff

AI can quickly sift through donor data, flag likely upgrade prospects, and even draft first-pass thank you notes or emails. These are things that used to take hours. Now they take minutes.

Use that time savings wisely. Let AI do the sorting and scheduling. You stay focused on the relationship-building. That’s still your lane and no bot is taking it.

Time saved is a donor connection gained.

Try platforms like:

  • Gravyty – For automatically generating personalized donor stewardship emails

  • ThankView – For video messaging that feels custom, even when scaled

  • Hum – For streamlining donor outreach based on engagement behavior

These tools aren’t about shortcuts. They’re about smart delegation. Let the systems tee up the basics, so your brain (and your energy) stay focused on meaningful donor conversations.

K&K Tip: Use AI-generated messages as drafts, not final sends. Add one human detail: something personal, specific, or mission-linked to keep the warmth in your touchpoints.

Read the (Digital) Room

The best fundraisers do their homework. AI helps you get to the insights quicker. With tools that surface donor preferences, past giving behavior, and even social media cues, you can walk into meetings more prepared.

But here’s the key: use those insights as a starting point, not a script. AI can give you data, but it can’t build trust. That’s your job.

Good data leads to better decisions.

AI tools like:

  • WealthEngine or DonorSearch – For donor capacity and affinity research

  • Blackbaud’s Raiser’s Edge NXT – With AI-powered predictive analytics

  • Virtuous – For donor signals, segmentation, and engagement scoring

These platforms give you a quicker read on who to prioritize and why. But remember, data is a door, not a decision. You still need to walk through it with discernment and care.

K&K Tip: Don't just target high-capacity donors. Use AI to uncover why they give. Then build your strategy around that.

Don’t Let AI Steal Your Voice

You can absolutely use AI to draft messages, create content, or test new campaign language. But don’t go on autopilot. If everything sounds like a template, donors will notice.

Use AI as a tool to spark ideas, not replace your voice. Your tone, your warmth, your specific knowledge of your donors… those are irreplaceable.

Your voice is part of your value.

You can use AI writing tools like:

  • ChatGPT – For first-draft emails, case statements, or campaign language

  • Writer – For on-brand tone control across teams

  • Jasper – For marketing-heavy copy like subject lines or headlines

But don’t hand the mic over completely. If your stewardship sounds like a bot, it’ll land like one. Use AI to generate options, but then revise to reflect your voice, your donor’s context, and the mission’s heart.

K&K Tip: Read every AI-generated message out loud. If it doesn’t sound like something you’d actually say to a donor, it’s not ready.

Put the “Why” Behind the “What”

AI can show you trends: which donors are lapsing, which events led to spikes in giving, who’s engaging with your content. But that data needs your context.

You bring the story behind the spreadsheet. You can ask: “What shifted in this donor’s life?” or “How can we show up in a more personal way?” AI can’t do that. You can.

AI can show you what’s happening… but not always why.

Use platforms like:

  • Bloomerang – With donor engagement scoring and retention data

  • Kindful – To map behavior trends and giving patterns

  • Google Looker Studio – To visualize insights across your donor journey

Once you have the numbers, go deeper. Ask the human questions: Why did giving drop here? Who might be struggling? Who hasn’t heard from us personally in too long?

K&K Tip: Schedule monthly “story behind the data” meetings. Pull your AI reports, then add the human layer. Patterns make more sense in context.

Be the Human AI Can’t Be

If your first instinct is to protect your turf from AI, take a breath. It’s not about replacement. It’s about evolution. Your role is becoming more strategic, more relational, more human than ever.

The future belongs to the fundraisers who can both understand the tech and stay rooted in the mission. Those who can use new tools without losing their old strengths.

K&K Tip: Make AI your intern, not your replacement. Let it prep your notes, build your dashboards, and offer ideas. Then you take it from there.

One Final Rule (and the Future of Non-Profit Fundraising): Stay Smart. Stay Human.

Use AI to streamline. Use it to segment donors. Use it to scale your fundraising efforts. The art of fundraising has always been about people. AI just helps you spend more of your time with them.

So don’t try to out-computer the computer. Let it do what it does best and then do what you do best: connect, listen, inspire, and ask donors to support your mission.

Let AI handle the tasks. You handle the trust.

Let’s get to work.

kere talovic
Next

From Donation to Devotion: How to Turn Donors Into Passionate Advocates